How to Make Popovers for Holiday Dinner Without a Special Pan

You can make popovers in a regular metal muffin pan. They’ll have a shorter, broader shape than popovers baked in a dedicated pan, but you can still get a crisp shell and a soft, airy center. For holiday dinner, the bigger challenge is reserving enough uninterrupted oven time to serve them freshly baked.

Choose the muffin pan you already own

Use a standard 12-cup metal muffin pan rated for 450°F. Skip paper liners and grease the cups directly. Mini and jumbo pans have different capacities, so don’t assume this batch will fit them or bake in the same time.

Metal is the best starting point: King Arthur Baking’s popover testing favors aluminum or steel/aluminum pans for their heat transfer. A silicone muffin mold isn’t an equivalent substitute for this method.

A basic batch of 12 muffin-pan popovers

This formula and baking sequence come from King Arthur Baking’s popover recipe.

  • 4 large eggs, warmed in their shells in warm water for 10 minutes
  • 1½ cups lukewarm milk
  • ¾ teaspoon table salt
  • 1½ cups (180 g) all-purpose flour
  • 3 tablespoons (43 g) melted butter, plus grease for the pan
  1. Heat a conventional oven to 450°F (232°C). Position a rack below the center, leaving room above for expansion. Thoroughly grease the muffin cups and surrounding surface.
  2. Whisk eggs, milk, and salt together. Whisk in flour until frothy, breaking up large lumps; small lumps are fine. Stir in melted butter.
  3. Divide among the cups, filling each about two-thirds to three-quarters full.
  4. Bake for 20 minutes without opening the door. Lower the setting to 350°F (177°C), keeping the door closed, and bake another 10–15 minutes until deeply golden.
  5. Carefully pierce each top to vent steam, remove from the pan, and serve promptly.

Does the muffin pan need preheating?

Not for the method above. The oven must be fully hot, but the greased muffin pan can start at room temperature. Other recipes use a preheated pan; follow one complete method rather than combining instructions from several.

The thin batter is intentional. Steam provides the lift, while the flour and eggs form the structure around it. Don’t add extra flour to make the mixture look like muffin batter, and don’t add baking powder or yeast.

Fit popovers into the holiday oven schedule

Give popovers the last baking slot before dinner. Set out your bowl, whisk, measured flour, and prepared pan earlier so mixing doesn’t compete with carving and making gravy.

If you’re baking them after the turkey comes out, include the time needed for the oven to climb to 450°F. The resting period isn’t automatically long enough for preheating, mixing, and baking. Write that full sequence into your dinner plan.

For example, if dinner is planned for 6 p.m., don’t wait until 5:30 to begin raising the oven temperature. Work backward from the baking steps, then add your oven’s preheating time and a little room for delays. Finish sides that need frequent stirring or oven checks before the popovers go in.

Set two labeled timers: one reminding you to lower the temperature and another to check the finished batch. It’s easy to miss the temperature change while carrying serving dishes to the table.

What if they don’t rise—or they sink?

Little rise: Check that the oven was fully preheated and that you measured the flour accurately. An oven thermometer can help identify a temperature problem. Also check that you used the intended pan size rather than spreading the batter across oversized cups.

Some settling after baking: This is normal as steam escapes. Popovers aren’t supposed to hold a perfectly rigid shape indefinitely. Judge them by their baked shell and interior as well as their height.

Different shapes across the pan: Uneven, leaning tops are part of their appearance. There’s no need to discard a batch because it doesn’t resemble a bakery display.

Keep the serving plan simple

Put butter on the table before the popovers finish, and have a serving basket or platter ready. Their hollow centers are also useful for catching a little gravy alongside turkey or roast beef.

For the best holiday presentation, bake them fresh rather than planning a long hold or next-day reheat. If fresh bread at the table matters more than the popover shape and texture, make-ahead dinner rolls may fit a crowded oven schedule better. But if you can reserve that final baking slot, your ordinary muffin pan is enough.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *